Just published on Impakter the article of a friend of mine, currently visiting Italy. I think that what she says is important and I wanted to share it with you.
You'll see that her reaction to the situation in Italy (and Europe) is very different from Thomas Friedman's, the New York Times brilliant columnist who also happens to be visiting Italy these days. And from my standpoint - and I think it matters, after all, I live in Italy, I've been here over 40 years, I read the Italian papers every day, interacting with my Italian friends and overhearing people in the street and at the bar where I go for my daily espresso - well, in the light of what I know of Italy, I honestly think my friend got it right and Friedman didn't quite get it. Yes, his analysis is excellent, spot on, but his conclusion is a tad too negative...
Judge for yourself, here's the beginning:
Writing from Italy, New York Times foreign affairs Op Ed columnist and Pulitzer winner Thomas L. Friedman claims in a new not-to-be-missed piece that he will “ruin your breakfast, lunch and dinner “ and he certainly does. He argues that if Putin, Trump and Bannon (presently roaming across Europe to raise trouble) succeed in breaking up our “community of democracies”, we are toast. There will be a power vacuum. Who will defend human rights and democracy? You certainly can’t count on China or Russia to save our Western values.
Italy seems to have inspired him, or perhaps helped clear his vision of what are the true challenges we are facing in Europe. And, as I too write from Italy, I can only agree with him. Up to a point. Let me clarify.
First, of all, he is right, it’s not only Brexit. Or the rise of populism. Or Putin’s interferences with elections in Europe. Or immigrant waves driven by “the environmental and political disorder from the south”, the war in Syria, the political mess in Libya, the poverty across Africa. Or the lack of cooperation within the European Union, with East European members (the Visegrad Group) most at fault, preventing any solution to the immigration problem. Or, because of Trump, an isolationist U.S. It’s all of them, a perfect storm. And the eye of the storm is in Italy.
...
Read the rest on Impakter, click here.
You'll see that her reaction to the situation in Italy (and Europe) is very different from Thomas Friedman's, the New York Times brilliant columnist who also happens to be visiting Italy these days. And from my standpoint - and I think it matters, after all, I live in Italy, I've been here over 40 years, I read the Italian papers every day, interacting with my Italian friends and overhearing people in the street and at the bar where I go for my daily espresso - well, in the light of what I know of Italy, I honestly think my friend got it right and Friedman didn't quite get it. Yes, his analysis is excellent, spot on, but his conclusion is a tad too negative...
Judge for yourself, here's the beginning:
Writing from Italy, New York Times foreign affairs Op Ed columnist and Pulitzer winner Thomas L. Friedman claims in a new not-to-be-missed piece that he will “ruin your breakfast, lunch and dinner “ and he certainly does. He argues that if Putin, Trump and Bannon (presently roaming across Europe to raise trouble) succeed in breaking up our “community of democracies”, we are toast. There will be a power vacuum. Who will defend human rights and democracy? You certainly can’t count on China or Russia to save our Western values.
Italy seems to have inspired him, or perhaps helped clear his vision of what are the true challenges we are facing in Europe. And, as I too write from Italy, I can only agree with him. Up to a point. Let me clarify.
First, of all, he is right, it’s not only Brexit. Or the rise of populism. Or Putin’s interferences with elections in Europe. Or immigrant waves driven by “the environmental and political disorder from the south”, the war in Syria, the political mess in Libya, the poverty across Africa. Or the lack of cooperation within the European Union, with East European members (the Visegrad Group) most at fault, preventing any solution to the immigration problem. Or, because of Trump, an isolationist U.S. It’s all of them, a perfect storm. And the eye of the storm is in Italy.
...
Read the rest on Impakter, click here.
Comments